The real difference is flavor variety, not the sleeve
Both boxes arrive in the same orange or brown gift box with a Brown Love sleeve, so the packaging won't help you decide. The meaningful choice is between an all-milk-chocolate selection and an assorted mix. That single difference affects who will enjoy the gift, how adventurous the tasting experience feels, and how much you'll spend per piece.
Below, I break down what each box actually contains, the available sizes, and the price per piece so you can match the box to the recipient and your budget.
Assorted vs Milk Chocolate: side-by-side
- Flavor variety: Assorted Bonbons: a mix of signature bonbons (specific flavors vary by box). Milk Chocolate Bonbons: all milk chocolate bonbons (flavors also vary).
- Available sizes: Assorted: 25-piece and 50-piece boxes. Milk Chocolate: 25-piece and 50-piece boxes.
- Price per piece (25 pc): Assorted: $3.02 per piece. Milk Chocolate: $1.73 per piece.
- Price per piece (50 pc): Assorted: $1.51 per piece. Milk Chocolate: $0.86 per piece.
What you get in the Assorted Bonbons box
- Assorted Bonbons with Brown Love Sleeve: Our most popular selection of assorted signature bonbons in our orange or brown gift box with a Brown Love sleeve. If you want a crowd-pleasing mix that lets people try different flavors, this is the box to choose.

Assorted Bonbons with Brown Love Sleeve - Assorted Bonbons with Brown Love Sleeve: Available in 25 pc and 50 pc boxes. Choose 25 pieces for a personal gift or 50 for sharing; the price per piece drops significantly at the larger size.
- Assorted Bonbons with Brown Love Sleeve: The actual selection of flavors within each box may vary from those pictured here. If you or your recipient have strong preferences, be aware that the exact flavors aren't guaranteed—this is a surprise mix.
What you get in the Milk Chocolate Bonbons box
- Milk Chocolate Bonbons with Brown Love Sleeve: A beautiful selection of our signature all milk chocolate bonbons in our orange or brown gift box with a Brown Love sleeve. This is the safest bet for milk chocolate lovers who prefer a consistent, creamy profile without dark or white chocolate pieces.

Milk Chocolate Bonbons with Brown Love Sleeve - Milk Chocolate Bonbons with Brown Love Sleeve: Available in 25 pc or 50 pc boxes. The smaller box suits a personal treat; the larger box works for parties or serious chocolate fans.
- Milk Chocolate Bonbons with Brown Love Sleeve: The actual selection of flavors within each box may vary from those pictured here. Even within milk chocolate, the specific bonbon flavors change, so expect some variety in fillings and shapes.
When the assorted box is the better buy
Choose the Assorted Bonbons if you're buying for a group, a office gift, or someone who enjoys discovering new flavors. The mix makes it easy for several people to find something they like, and the 50-piece box brings the per-piece cost down to about $1.51—reasonable for a gift that feels generous.
Keep in mind that the assortment changes, so it's not ideal for someone who has a very specific favorite. But if the recipient is adventurous or you're unsure of their preferences, the variety is a strength.
When the milk chocolate box wins
Pick the Milk Chocolate Bonbons if you know the recipient loves milk chocolate and nothing else. The all-milk selection delivers a consistent, creamy experience without any dark or white chocolate surprises. It's also the more budget-friendly option: at $43.20 for 25 pieces, it's about $1.73 per bonbon, and the 50-piece box drops to roughly $0.86 per piece.
That lower price makes it a strong choice for larger gifts or when you want to give generously without overspending. The trade-off is less variety—but for a milk chocolate devotee, that's exactly the point.
What the sleeve and box tell you
Both boxes come with the Brown Love sleeve and a gift box in your choice of orange or brown. The sleeve is a decorative touch that makes the box ready for gifting without extra wrapping. However, the sleeve doesn't indicate flavor or ingredients, so if you need allergen or dietary information, check the product page or contact the store—the supplied information doesn't include those details.
Also note that neither box specifies storage instructions in the provided details. For chocolate, a cool, dry place is standard, but confirm with the store if you need precise guidance.
A quick decision framework
If you're still torn, ask yourself: Does the recipient prefer milk chocolate exclusively, or do they enjoy trying different flavors? If milk chocolate only, go with the Milk Chocolate Bonbons. If they like variety or you're buying for a group, the Assorted Bonbons is the safer crowd-pleaser. And if budget is a concern, the Milk Chocolate box offers a lower price per piece at both sizes.
Whichever you choose, both boxes deliver the same elegant presentation with the Brown Love sleeve, so you can't go wrong on the gift-wrapping front.



